The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

New flavours are the icing on the cake at Hearthe in Stanmore

Lenny Ann Low
Lenny Ann Low

Hearthe slots into the former Mrs Underwood site beside Stanmore Station and library.
Hearthe slots into the former Mrs Underwood site beside Stanmore Station and library.Brook Mitchell

Cafe

If you sit at the right table at Hearthe, master pastry chef Christopher Thé's new cafe in Stanmore, you can watch the creator of the world's most Instagrammed cake look in an oven.

Or stand, calmly answering queries from staff members about the four types of cream available to accompany his new range of signature cakes, while he prepares roast pork with crackling, rice congee with smoked barramundi dumplings or fried kipler hash with smoked salmon.

I don't know if Thé, who starts work around 3am, is preparing all the Hearthe menu items every day. But he is working, head-down, arms gently whirring between bench top, oven door, chopping board and ingredient bowls, with a serene round-the-clock tenacity that centres the cafe's buzzing open kitchen .

Advertisement
He created the world's most Instagrammed cake, but Christopher Thé has now turned his skills towards native ingredients.
He created the world's most Instagrammed cake, but Christopher Thé has now turned his skills towards native ingredients.Brook Mitchell

Years of working nights in fine dining, and honing the cake magic that put Black Star Pastry, and Thé's famous strawberry watermelon cake, on the global map, has inured him to working pre-dawn to day's end.

"I'm the father of twins," he says. "So this is nothing."

After selling Black Star Pastry to the Jackalope Group in 2019, Thé spent two years looking for the right cafe premises. He settled on the former Mrs Underwood site, originally a butcher shop, on a wide-pathed corner site beside Stanmore Station and library.

The Geraldton wax cheesecake is a creamy, fragrant baked goat's curd wonder.
The Geraldton wax cheesecake is a creamy, fragrant baked goat's curd wonder.Brook Mitchell
Advertisement

"When I walked into this cafe, it felt like home," he says. "It's a beautiful room. It's Federation and I've always lived in Federation places."

It also had the back-end space he needed.

"Every Black Star, it was always too small after a few months," he says. "This is roomy, we're composting out the back, building a sustainable process. I just love the place."

The paperbark dacquoise conjures eucalyptus leaf and the sooty zing of a bush campfire.
The paperbark dacquoise conjures eucalyptus leaf and the sooty zing of a bush campfire.Brook Mitchell

So do a raft of locals who fill large outdoor wooden tables and dinky round ones inside the bright, light-flooded, curve-fronted shop. Framed by jugs of cut rosemary, potted monstera and birds nest fern plants and cream tiles accented with blue and acqua stripes, they help themselves to a tap offering chilled, sparkling or ambient water.

Advertisement

The menu, which swings between savoury and sweet dishes, includes a hearty, slow-cooked meal of the day, ranging from paperbark lamb to roast pork, kangaroo Wellington or chicken tagine. 

There are, of course, heady signature cakes, along with pastries, pies and filled rolls using seven kinds of house-baked bread. Coffee comes from the Little Marionette and there are milkshakes, smoothies, juices and iced tea.

The hibiscus cake is a snowy symphony of basil olive oil sponge.
The hibiscus cake is a snowy symphony of basil olive oil sponge.Brook Mitchell

There's also beer, wine and three cocktails including a life-enhancing Green Ant gin and tonic.

A key aspect of Hearthe, an amalgam of art, heart, earth and Thé, is its founder's exploration of indigenous ingredients, including herbs, flowers, spices and ground powders. Most are found in the signature cakes, but they feature in the luscious bacon and egg tarts, egg and bacon rolls, golden handmade meat pies, saltbush scones, cream varieties and dishes including native Akoya oysters kilpatrick and kangaroo wellington.

Advertisement

The Geraldton wax cheesecake, a creamy, fragrant baked goat's curd wonder, merges desert lime, strawberry gum biscuit, ermine cream, rose petals and a crown of Geraldton wax jelly bubbles.

Savoury options include an egg and bacon tart.
Savoury options include an egg and bacon tart.Brook Mitchell

The paperbark dacquoise, a mix of crunchy, chewy, flaky textures, conjures eucalyptus leaf and the sooty zing of a bush campfire, the latter due to Tasmanian oak chip smoke injected into the chocolate ganache.

The hibiscus cake, a snowy symphony of basil olive oil sponge spiked with gin, features raspberry gel, hibiscus marshmallow, candied hibiscus and speckled lilly pilly. It's a mouth sensation, soft, fruity, sweet and strong but not overwhelmingly so.

"A lot of native ingredients and flavours can be confronting," Thé says. "A little bit adult, sometimes bitter, sometimes strange, sometimes very acidic. So you really have to be careful to pair it with something people are comfortable with, like a cheesecake."

Advertisement
Breakfast tart.
Breakfast tart.Brook Mitchell

He's also aware how fast menu items go each day. The "Every Thing Sold Out Sorry" door sign is often up in the afternoon. Thé is working on that challenge, too. 

Being responsible for a globally famous means cake also means customers are hungry to revel in his kitchen wizardry. 

As lunch winds down, a man with two eskies arrives to commune with a slice of Geraldton wax cheesecake, before loading up several pre-ordered full-size versions and walking very carefully and slowly away.

The low-down

Advertisement

Hearthe

Vibe Federation corner cafe serving master pastry chef Christopher Thé's beautiful native ingredient-flavoured cakes, savoury dishes, bread, cocktails and drinks.

Go-to dish(es) Baked egg and bacon tart with white beans and saltbush, followed by a slice of paperbark dacquoise and a sparking cascara iced tea.

Continue this series

Sydney hit list April 2023: Hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out, right now
Up next
Thit kho pappardelle (left) with congee en croute and mala wings.

Hello Auntie chef serves Vietnamese-inspired snacks at late-night drinking spot Hey Chu

The second stage of Hotel Downing’s revamp on Castlereagh Street draws inspiration from Vietnam’s late-night drinking culture.

Ta Ta Ta serves Roman-style pizza by the slice.

Pizza by the slice heats up in Sydney as Merivale and Michelin-starred chef open two new spots

Totti’s chef Mike Eggert will soon open Oti in Merivale’s Ivy precinct, while Ta Ta Ta Pizza opens in a backstreet in Bondi Junction.

Previous
St Siandra at The Spit.

Soak up the endless summer at St Siandra at The Spit

With knock-out views, a private stretch of sand and boats bobbing on blue waters, this new waterfront spot makes the most of Sydney’s endless summer.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Lenny Ann LowLenny Ann Low is a writer and podcaster.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement