Crimes against coffee: too hot by half

Temperature is a tough call ... How hot should a coffee be?
Temperature is a tough call ... How hot should a coffee be? Photo: Brianne Makin

WHEN it comes to coffee, how hot is hot enough? And if you ask for it hotter than it is customarily served, should the barista throw a tantrum and behave like a chef who has been asked to cook a well-done steak, or simply give you what you want?

It's a tough call - involving chemical reactions, damaged taste buds, bad coffee habits, loss of dignity and, frankly, profound ignorance.

David Makin, co-owner of Axil Coffee Roasters in Burwood Road, Hawthorn, has won five Victorian barista championships, two national titles and finished second in the World Barista Championships in 2008. He has no doubt as to the answer.

''The customer is paying and, therefore, we will serve the coffee as hot as we realistically can if that's what's asked for,'' he says.

Mind you, the affable and obliging Makin winces as he says it. Because he, of all people, knows perfectly well that those who want their coffee served at anything above the gentle 65 degrees at which it is served at Axil are doing themselves, and the coffee, no favours. It works like this:

''The big thing is the milk,'' Makin says. ''A Maillard reaction takes place past a certain temperature and the effect of that is to break down the natural sugars in the milk, making it bitter.

Sweet science: David Makin.
Sweet science: David Makin. Photo: Eddie Jim

''Once you remove natural sweetness from the milk, you will tend to add back sweetness with refined sugar, which is nasty. The body can break down natural sugars but it struggles with the refined stuff.''

Milk, which boils at 86 degrees, should be served at no more than 65 degrees. Because what happens between those two temperatures is the Maillard reaction. Simple as that. But why has it become an issue?

''It comes,'' Makin says, ''from the fact that so many Australians drink instant coffee at home. They make it with boiling water and drink it far too hot.


''In Europe and the US, people drink a lot more filter coffee, which is seldom served as hot as we drink instant in this country. Their palates are better trained by their in-home experiences than ours.''

The process of extracting espresso coffee with steam is simple enough. But there is a world of difference between the machines that people such as Makin and his baristas use and the machine you may see (or hear) in a corner shop or a country cafe.

Steam is generated and pumped through both the coffee and the milk. But the top machines have twin boilers that allow temperatures and pressures for these processes to be set independently. Coffee, for example, is extracted at 92-96 degrees.

One of the most nauseating blunders occurs, however, when the person making the coffee simply tops up leftover milk in a jug, and pumps through more steam.

''When that happens, even if the temperature does not go above 65 degrees, a Maillard reaction will take place in the previously heated milk and sour the drink,'' Makin says. ''And that's why you will see baristas who work with speciality [high-quality] coffee washing and refilling their milk jugs constantly.''

Another aspect of coffee service is cup temperature: a responsible cafe operator will always serve coffee in warm or even hot cups.

But in essence, it is the entire package that delivers great coffee - not just the temperature, not just the barista, and not just the beans.

''If we were to work with a cafe making sour coffee and recalibrate the temperatures while everything else remained the same, it is quite likely that, in terms of the overall experience, you would not be able to tell the difference,'' Makin says. ''The coffee would still taste terrible.''