Do you really need to brown meat to ‘seal in’ the juices? Five big kitchen myths, debunked

Food myths come from many sources, and cooks (including me) have swallowed lots of them. The five notions below are the ones I’ve believed in the longest – and been most mystified by. I consulted the latest studies, called up experts, bought two extra rice cookers and tracked down farmers to find out once and for all: truth or myth?

TRUTH OR MYTH: Never use soap to wash a cast-iron pan

Apart from the best way to cook rice, nothing gets cooking-science types more riled up than cast-iron pans.

For cooking, cast iron has a great weight and a porous surface – slightly rough, compared with smooth stainless steel or a non-stick coating – that makes it ideal for searing. The surface absorbs oil, which hardens over heat and over time into a shiny, nearly non-stick patina. This process is called seasoning, not in the sense of adding salt to taste but in the sense of developing a well-used, trusted tool.

For cleaning, the prohibition against soap comes from a time when all soap was made with lye, which could eat through a patina in minutes. And it’s true that most of the time, soap is unnecessary. Most of your cleaning power should come from hot water and gentle scrubbing or brushing, the way cast-iron pots like Chinese woks and Indian kadai are traditionally cleaned.

But sometimes a batch of bacon or a crusty steak leaves more residue in the pan than hot water can handle. A few drops of dishwashing liquid and a plastic scrubber will degrease your pan just enough to move on to the final cleaning step. You want the pan to still have a sheen when you place it over low heat to dry out.

And if you use too much soap or scrub a little too hard (or if a houseguest runs your prized vintage Wagner through the dishwasher), it may remove a little of the patina. But just as a patina can be built, it can be rebuilt: This is when soap comes in handy. With a metal pad, you can scour any rust down to the cast-iron surface, then start the seasoning process over again.

VERDICT: False. As long as you’re not using scouring powder or drain cleaner, a little bit of soap won’t harm your cast-iron pan.

TRUTH OR MYTH: Pasta cooking water should taste as salty as the ocean

Where did this myth come from? Probably not from Italy, where “salted water” is understood to mean a palmful of salt in a standard five-litre pasta pot. (The myth Italian cooks argue about is when, not whether, to add the salt.)

And more important, what does the ocean taste like, anyway? According to NASA, the average salinity of the Earth’s oceans is 3.5 per cent by weight. That works out to 35 grams of salt per litre of water, or half a cup per gallon in US home-cook terms.

To test the myth, I cooked eight batches of spaghetti at salt levels ranging from none to Pacific Ocean (3 per cent) to Mediterranean Sea (4 per cent). I can confirm that seawater is too salty. As I worked my way up from a teaspoon to a tablespoon of salt per gallon, the pasta was noticeably undersalted. I most liked water that tasted as salty as a light chicken stock, or 2 tablespoons per gallon of water.

Of course, the salted water rule doesn’t apply to all kinds of noodles. Italian pasta doesn’t contain salt, so salt is added to the cooking water.

Asian wheat noodles like udon and lo mein have alkaline salts added to the dough, and they are traditionally cooked in unsalted water. Rice noodles are unsalted; they are also typically cooked in unsalted water.

VERDICT: False. Salt to taste.

TRUTH OR MYTH: Always wash rice until the water runs clear before cooking

For centuries, the process of milling rice – white or brown, sticky or sweet – produced bran, chaff and dust, and storing it brought vermin, fungi and spoilage. So for reasons of hygiene, safety and general anti-ick, rice absolutely did have to be washed. This is done in multiple changes of water until the water runs clear.

Today, milled rice is sealed in oxygen-free tanks, and according to the most recent research, washing doesn’t affect the way the rice cooks. Modern growers say washing is unnecessary. So is there any need to? And if so, is a quick rinse enough or are we talking about multiple changes of water?

The answer depends on what kind of rice you’re cooking.

Instead of measuring short, medium and long grains, it makes more sense to think of the world’s two main varieties of rice: indica and japonica. Most rice is indica; it can be long- or medium-grain and includes Indian basmati, Thai jasmine, Carolina, and par-cooked rice such as Golden Sella, used for jollof rice.

Japonica rice includes Spanish bomba, Italian arborio and Japanese rice like koshihikari and nishiki; most, but not all of it, is short-grain.

All of it now arrives in our kitchens milled, cleaned and lightly dusted in its own starch. But at the molecular level, the way the starches behave is slightly different. As the microscopic granules burst while cooking, japonica releases more sticky starch. That’s (part of) why indica cooks up lighter and drier, and japonica is denser with a pearly sheen.

I bought an extra rice cooker and cooked three kinds of washed and unwashed rice side by side: koshihikari, jasmine and basmati.

For the indica rices (jasmine and basmati), the difference between unwashed and rinsed rice was imperceptible. For the japonica, to my taste the washed rice had just a microdose less starch.

VERDICT: False. Short- and medium-grain (japonica) rice can be washed to reduce stickiness, but it’s not required; long-grain rice (indica) just needs a rinse.

TRUTH OR MYTH: Have all of your ingredients prepared and your cooking oil heated before starting to cook

So many dishes around the world begin by cooking some combination of aromatics (garlic, ginger, chillies, lemongrass) and vegetables (onions, celery, carrots) in hot fat, whether as a sofrito, a mirepoix, a recaito or a ginisa. And many published recipes instruct you to prepare all of the ingredients separately, heat the oil (or butter or lard) until “shimmering” and then begin to cook.

But years ago, I started to rush the process by adding ingredients directly from the cutting board to the pan with the oil. Now I set the pan over low heat and warm the ingredients as I work, stirring in each new ingredient as it’s ready. The heat goes up only once everything is minced, chopped and coated evenly with oil.

The myth that all ingredients need to be prepared before any cooking starts comes to us from restaurant kitchens, where the concept of “mise en place” (French for “put in place”) is fundamental.

Professional cooks start with prepped ingredients and cook them to order, with attention focused on that one skillet (or wok or tadka) at a time. For stir-frying, where the cook is constantly moving the food around in the pan, this works great. And when frying, starting with super-hot oil is integral to the cooking process.

But for slower food, such as soups and stews, it’s fine to start the pan over low heat, and turn the heat to high once everything is in. Diced vegetables like onions and celery take longer to cook than minced aromatics like ginger and garlic, so put the vegetables in first. They will soften, turn golden, and then eventually caramelise.

VERDICT: False. When cooking something in a flash, preheated oil and prepped ingredients are necessities. But for other recipes, low and slow is a great start.

TRUTH OR MYTH: Always brown meat at the beginning of the cooking process to “seal in” the juices

Historians like to argue about when humans discovered cooking, but they do agree on this: Roasting meat (or poultry, fish, reptiles or amphibians) over an open flame was our first step toward home cooking.

But it wasn’t until a century ago that French scientist Louis Camille Maillard identified the source of the delicious flavours produced by cooking proteins and sugars over high, dry heat. Maillard reactions are what make dry-roasted things like bread crusts, dumpling skirts and chicken skin taste and smell so good.

A lot of cooking is about generating those reactions. But that browned surface doesn’t actually keep the juices in the meat.

Many traditional stews are built without it: a Central American jocon, a West African mafe and a Provencal daube all skip browning and rely on other ingredients to deepen their flavours.

Many stew recipes from European traditions call for a first step of browning the meat – sometimes “all over” – a process that creates extra mess and tedium. It isn’t about keeping the meat juicy or tender; it’s about building those delicious cooked bits at the bottom of the pan, the fond, to flavour the cooking liquid.

There are many other ways to make meat succulent – poaching it as in Hainanese chicken or braising it as in Indian curries – but browning isn’t one of them. Skip it if you wish, and try letting your stews rest overnight instead to deepen the flavours.

VERDICT: False. Browning is great for dry-heat dishes like steaks and roasts but unnecessary for stews and braises.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times