The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

St. Alma in Freshwater is more Mex than Tex

Terry Durack
Terry Durack

St. Alma in Freshwater is the type of place you'll want to hang out at on the way to or from the beach.
St. Alma in Freshwater is the type of place you'll want to hang out at on the way to or from the beach.Louie Douvis

14.5/20

Mexican$$

Mexican food has always been fun, but now it's getting serious as well. What used to be Tex-Mex is now more Mex than Tex. Closer to the real thing. Made with real Mexicans and Australians, working together.

It could have gone the other way, down the cheesy enchilada road – but it didn't. We're now seeing eateries focused on regions such as the Yucatan Peninsula, Oaxaca (Wahaca), Mexico City.

They're in beachside suburbs for the playa atmosphere, and do well on the North Shore, where legions of teenagers grew up on surfing from Taco Tuesdays to Corona beer Friday nights.

Advertisement
Hard-shell tacos of salmon, avocado, pico de gallo salsa, jalapeno and lime.
Hard-shell tacos of salmon, avocado, pico de gallo salsa, jalapeno and lime.Louie Douvis

St. Alma's Jack Leary and Tim Christensen are part of that journey. Leary used to hang out at Manly's Chica Bonita, where Christensen was chef. They joined forces to open Alma in Avalon four years ago, and have now expanded to Freshwater.

Their first job was transforming a former bank into a contemporary space, fringed by kitchens, bars and picture windows to the street. Mission accomplished. St. Alma looks and feels great.

They've been working remotely with new chef Maximo Martinez before his arrival from Mexico City this month, to create a "coastal Mexican" menu.

Al pastor tacos with slow-cooked, marinated pork belly, grilled pineapple and watermelon radish.
Al pastor tacos with slow-cooked, marinated pork belly, grilled pineapple and watermelon radish.Louie Douvis
Advertisement

Yes, it starts with the money-spinning "guac and chips" – of course it does – but goes on to sikil pak, a toasty Mayan pumpkin seed dip, soft-shell crab tortillas, chilli octopus, corn truffle empanadas, agave short ribs and banana leaf fish.

The window-side booths are the best seats in the house, tables are flanked with wicker or bentwood chairs, lighting is clever, and staff are savvy. Drinks are taken seriously, but while six different margaritas and a variety of tequila and mezcal cocktails are offered, most still go for the classic marg.

A likeable, interesting, multi-layered wine list runs with a focus on chardonnay and shiraz, and there are plenty of booze-free drinks as well. (Freshy even has its own no-alcohol bottle shop Sans Drinks, directly opposite Vintage Cellars.)

Chocolate churro bowl.
Chocolate churro bowl.Louie Douvis

A Tommy's margarita of reposado tequila, agave and lime ($18) is fresh and feisty, ready to take on crisp little hard-shell tacos of salmon, avocado, pico de gallo salsa, jalapeno and lime, scattered with black sesame seeds like ants at a picnic.

Advertisement

Tortillas are the more flavourful corn variant, sourced from La Tortilleria​ in Melbourne, and the soft tacos that utilise them are designed to be more than a mouthful of meaningless pap. An al pastor ($7) has the requisite slow-cooked, marinated pork belly teamed with grilled pineapple and watermelon radish; meaty and satisfying.

It's tempting to stay with the snacks all night. A tiradito of kingfish-like amberjack ($19) ticks the ceviche box, but it's the crisp chicken tinga empanadas ($15) that get my undivided attention. The shells are impressively thin, made in-house from imported masa, and the shredded chicken in chipotle and tomato sauce is warm and balanced.

Chicken empanadas with impressively thin house-made shells.
Chicken empanadas with impressively thin house-made shells.Louie Douvis

A pleasant dish of halloumi comes off the grill with an agave and thyme caramel ($18) and a generous shower of nutty, crushed praline; not quite sure why.

The one larger dish I try is of confit duck ($39) with black beans, spinach and clumps of Oaxaca cheese made by Marrickville's Vannella, topped with crisp sweet potato straws. It probably works better on paper than it does IRL. While the confit technique is good and the separate elements are fine, there's no oomph, acidity, contrast, or anything to bring it together.

Advertisement

For dessert, los coconut churros ($18) has become something of a signature for both Alma and St. Alma, and I can see why. The extruded churro is the sugar-dusted doughnut of your dreams, shaped into a bowl that holds a soft coconut gelato squiggled with chocolate and more crushed nuts.

Confit duck with black beans, spinach and clumps of Oaxaca cheese.
Confit duck with black beans, spinach and clumps of Oaxaca cheese.Louie Douvis

Ambitious owners who want to expand people's perceptions of Mexican cuisine; a place you want to hang at on the way to or from the beach; and Mexican chefs doing hands-on Mexican food that's built for sharing over a drink or two? Sounds like serious fun.

The low-down

Vibe Fresh-as Mexi-cantina with cocktails

Advertisement

Go-to dish Al pastor pork belly taco, $7

Drinks Margaritas, tequilas, Mexican and local beers and strong Australian-led wine list

Continue this series

Sydney restaurant reviews 2022
Up next
Potato skordalia is a clever mix of flavours that are at once fresh but familiar.

Feel-good dining anyone can get behind at Massimo Bottura's Refettorio

Sydney's Refettorio serves nourishing three-course vegetarian lunches to those who need them most, four days a week, but every second Thursday evening, it opens to the paying public.

It's an instant tapas party, upstairs and down, at this reborn Enmore Road venue.

Join the Spanish party at Bar Louise in Enmore

It's an instant tapas party, upstairs and down, at this reborn Enmore Road venue.

Previous
Lasagne spring roll stuffed with beef, mozzarella and tomato.

A nod to mod Italian at Enoteca Ponti in Potts Point

One of Potts Point's most storied restaurant sites is now channelling Roman wine bars of the 1950s.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Terry DurackTerry Durack is the chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and Good Food.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement