The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

The Butler

Terry Durack
Terry Durack

Tropical air: The terrace has great views of the Domain and city skyline.
Tropical air: The terrace has great views of the Domain and city skyline.Sahlan Hayes

14/20

Contemporary$$

Merry Christmas, Sydney. Your prezzie is to have one of your best dining spaces given back to you, right in time for the festive season. What was Mogens Bay Esbensen's nouvelle cuisine Butler's in the '80s, and later the Polese family's modern Italian Mezzaluna, is now, after some time wrapped up under the tree, The Butler.

The light in this room has always been pure magic, flooding down from the top level, washing over the main dining room and cascading over the broad covered verandah, decked out in greenery. The view of The Domain and the city skyline changes almost by the minute whether you're seated inside or out. As the Good Food Guide said back in 1984, it has what real estate agents call 'the Manhattan effect'.

With all that going on, you don't necessarily have to try too hard, but that hasn't stopped Hamish Watts and Ben Carroll of Applejack Hospitality (Bondi Hardware, Kirribilli's The Botanist and Neutral Bay's SoCal). Their smart new contemporary concept combines a buzzy bar vibe and French/Caribbean flavours via exec chef James Privett, formerly of The Cut.

Advertisement
Grilled octopus, white beans and sherry vinegar.
Grilled octopus, white beans and sherry vinegar.Sahlan Hayes

For anyone not entirely certain what constitutes French/Caribbean cooking, it apparently covers such things as Tabasco prawns with mango salsa and coconut quinoa; jerk tofu, chilli salsa and broccolini; and black bean boulettes with couscous and collard greens. But don't let that put you off; there's quite a bit of good, well put-together non-French/Caribbean dishes here as well. Like a smashing Lyonnaise sausage turned into party-smarty sausage rolls ($12) and the cutest little boudin noir slider ($6) of grilled blood sausage, charred corn salsa and capsicum relish served with gaufrettes, those cross-cut potato chips that look like rice chex.

High-rise pale wooden tables and woven cane-backed stools inside descend to low-line wicker tables and chairs tucked in among the plants on the terrace. Plantation ceiling fans, botanical murals and a colourful back bar add an even more tropical air.

There's more gravitas to the food here than I had expected, and some mag-worthy styling (chips don't just come in a bowl – The Butler serves them in a clip-top jar.) Finely sliced swordfish cured with dill and coriander seed ($22) is topped with fleshy little clams, outcrops of sea bananas and the crunch of fennel crumb. A hearty, grilled duck sausage and slashes of duck confit ($28) sitting on a parsley puree under a camouflage of tumbled pickled beetroot, shaved target beetroot, mint, pistachio and shaved celery is a crowd-pleaser.

Duck sausage, confit leg, pickled beetroot and celery.
Duck sausage, confit leg, pickled beetroot and celery.Sahlan Hayes
Advertisement

Creole-spiced lamb ribs ($25) are enjoyable for their fall-off-the-bone tender meat and tangy walnut and pomegranate dressing, but the Creole spicing feels powdery and tastes a little muddy.

I suggest only dedicated chocaholics order the chocolate mousse with bitter chocolate sorbet and caramel whip ($16), which is every bit as dense and sweet as it sounds. As for the drinking side of things, a lot of effort has gone into the cocktail, martini, bubbles and carafes of Pimms or sangria side of things, and there's a serviceable wine list divided equally between France and Australia. A fleshy, savoury Geoff Merrill 2007 'Bush Vine' Shiraz, Grenache & Mourvedre from McLaren Vale ($11/$50) is noteworthy for its value.

This early in the piece, service is as up and down as the staircase, some whip-smart and some clueless. But The Butler brings a new mood to the area; a confident fusion of Kings Cross' party vibe with Potts Point's food, delivered with style. That's what butlers do.

THE LOW-DOWN
Best bit: 
Categorically lovely views.
Worst bit: The pump-up-the-volume music.
Go-to dish: Duck sausage, confit leg, pickled beetroot, celery.

Terry Durack is chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and senior reviewer for the Good Food Guide. This rating is based on the Good Food Guide scoring system.

Continue this series

Cracking Christmas catch-ups spots for Sydney 2017
Up next
The Rozelle venue is lifting the lid on its redesign.

New menu and redesign for 3 Weeds in Rozelle

With its refurbishment awaiting council approval, 3 Weeds has taken a novel approach to its redesign.

Chicken cotoletta, peas, broccolini and lemon parmesan cream.

Digging up treasure at Parramatta's Husk & Vine

Jamie is already here; Neil is coming, and so is George. Parramatta is shaping up to be Sydney's next satellite dining destination.

Previous
Hand-rolled rabbit casarecce pasta gets its magnificent green from the peas and nettles.

Why Merivale's new restaurant Fred's is the hottest in Sydney right now

Fred's is Danielle Alvarez's long-awaited restaurant for Merivale. It features the kitchen of your dreams - with a menu to match.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Terry DurackTerry Durack is the chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and Good Food.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement